Every Single Garage Sale Mystery Movie (In Release Order)

Jennifer loves to attend Garage sales and finds special things to resell in her shop, but her interest in garage sales ends up solving complex crimes that start to occur around the city. Here is the list of all Garage Sale Mystery Movies In order of release

  • Garage Sale Mysteries: Garage Sale Mystery (2013)
  • Garage Sale Mysteries: All That Glitters (2014)
  • Garage Sale Mysteries: The Deadly Room (2015)
  • Garage Sale Mysteries: The Wedding Dress (2015)
  • Garage Sale Mysteries: Guilty Until Proven Innocent (2016)
  • Garage Sale Mysteries: The Novel Murders (2016)
  • Garage Sale Mysteries: The Art or Murder (2017)
  • Garage Sale Mysteries: The Beach Murder (2017)
  • Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder By Text (2017)
  • Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder Most Medieval (2017)
  • Garage Sale Mysteries: A Case of Murder (2017)
  • Garage Sale Mysteries: The Pandora’s Box Murders (2018)
  • Garage Sale Mysteries: The Mask Murder (2018)
  • Garage Sale Mysteries: Picture a Murder (2018)
  • Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder in D Minor (2018)
  • Garage Sale Mysteries: Search & Seized (2019)
What Order Should I Watch The Garage Sale Mystery Movies In

About Garage Sale Mystery Movie Series

Based on Suzi Weinert’s novel, Garage Sale Stalker, the first Garage Sale film was premiered on Hallmark Channel in 2013 and proved entertaining and received a positive review from viewers and critics.

After the success of the first film, Garage Sale Mysteries: Garage Sale Mystery (2013), Hallmark continued developing sequels After sequels and make the series one of the famous mystery creation of Hallmark.

Garage Sale Mystery Movies In Order: What Order Are The Garage Sale Films?

The film series narrates the story of Jennifer Shannon, who lives with her family and runs an antique shop called Rags to Riches. Jennifer has a unique skill of observing things which makes her start investigating crime mysteries.

How Many Garage Sale Mystery Movies Are There?

Currently, there are 16 Garage Sale Mystery movies. All of them star Lori Loughlin in the lead role of Jennifer Shannon, who runs an antique shop and solves crime mysteries.

What Order Should I Watch The Garage Sale Mystery Movies In?

Garage Sale Mystery movies are connected to each other and are based on a similar storyline. To properly understand the story and the characters, it is essential to watch Garage Sale Mystery movies in order.

All the Garage Sale mystery movies set in a linear timeline. Here is the list of all Garage Sale Mystery Movies In order of release

A still from Garage Sale Mysteries: Garage Sale Mystery (2013). it is the first movie on the list of all Garage Sale Mystery series
Image: ©Hallmark/Crown Media

Garage Sale Mysteries: Garage Sale Mystery (2013)

Jennifer Shannon is living with her family and is enjoying her work of treasure hunting prowess. After she attends a recent garage sale, a series of crimes and attempts to theft start to occur around the city. Initially, she ignores it, but the situation becomes serious for her when she gets the news about the murder of one of her close friends.

When she starts to examine all the burglaries, she notices that they are connected to the recent garage sale she attended. Jennifer decides to uncover the truth. She teams up with Detective Adam Iverson, and together, they start to investigate all the events.

A still from Garage Sale Mysteries: All That Glitters (2014). it is the second movie on the list of all Garage Sale Mystery series
Image: ©Hallmark/Crown Media

Garage Sale Mysteries: All That Glitters (2014)

After the first film’s events, Jennifer continues the work she loves to do, looking for treasure. She attends a Garage sale in which, just hours after auctioning off an abandoned storage unit full of unique items to her, She learns that her friend Martin, the self-storage facility owner, gets murdered.

After learning about Martin, she immediately finds some connection between the murder, garage sale, and the disgruntled customer. Jennifer teams up with Detective Lynwood to uncover the absolute truth.

A still from Garage Sale Mysteries: The Deadly Room (2015). it is the third movie on the list of all Garage Sale Mystery series
Image: ©Hallmark/Crown Media

Garage Sale Mysteries: The Deadly Room (2015)

Jennifer’s real estate agent friend Adrian invites her to show her a centuries-old property, but there are rumors around the town that one of the rooms of the old property is cursed. To ensure that all these rumors are fake, Adrain Adrain decides to sleep in the cursed room for a night, but the police discover her dead body in the morning.

All the camera recordings and evidence show that she died due to natural causes, but Jennifers found something unusual about this dead. Jennifers starts her investigation to uncover the actual truth.

A still from Garage Sale Mysteries: The Wedding Dress (2015). it is the fourth movie on the list of all Garage Sale Mystery series
Image: ©Hallmark/Crown Media

Garage Sale Mysteries: The Wedding Dress (2015)

After the events in the previous film, Jennifers continues to live her everyday life. She starts to travel around town, finding garage sales, estate sales, and storage locker auctions so that she can get something unique and antique to sell in her shop.

While doing so, she finds a wedding dress connected to a cold case. On the day the groom wore the dress for his wedding, he goes missing, and nobody has any clue about where he is! Jennifers, who has now gained experience in solving mysteries, take on this cold case to cover the truth.

A still from Garage Sale Mysteries: Guilty Until Proven Innocent (2016). it is the fifth movie on the list of all Garage Sale Mystery series
Image: ©Hallmark/Crown Media

Garage Sale Mysteries: Guilty Until Proven Innocent (2016)

Jennifers close friend Sandra decides to close her antique shop, so she invites Jennifer to collect all the exquisite pieces, but when she reaches Sandra’s shop, she gets shocked to find a dead body.

When the police start her investigation, her friend Sandra becomes the prime suspect and gets arrested by police. Jennifer has faith in her friend and decides to start her investigation to uncover the truth and protect her friend.

A still from Garage Sale Mysteries: The Novel Murders (2016). it is the sixth movie on the list of all Garage Sale Mystery series

Garage Sale Mysteries: The Novel Murders (2016)

Jennifer is gifted with sharp observation skills, which helps her find unique items to resell in her shop and solve complex crimes. Jennifer gets an order from one of her customers, and she decides to deliver it to his home, but when she reaches her customer’s house, she finds that he has been murdered.

After observing the murder spot and dead body, she finds that the case is similar to a murder in a classic mystery novel, and the suspect might be a serial killer. She starts to investigate and find out the one who is behind all this.

A still from Garage Sale Mysteries: The Art or Murder (2017). it is the seventh movie on the list of all Garage Sale Mystery series

Garage Sale Mysteries: The Art or Murder (2017)

Jennifer takes the responsibility to organize a charity garage sale event this year. While going through the arrangement for the charity program, Jennifer finds a dead body in the attic of one of the residences.

Because of Jennifer’s experience in solving crime mysteries, she decides to investigate the dead body with Detective Frank Lynwood. Soon into the investigation, Lynwood gets convinced that the death was an accident, but Jennifers listen to her instincts and continue her investigation.

A still from Garage Sale Mysteries: The Beach Murder (2017). it is the eighth movie on the list of all Garage Sale Mystery series

Garage Sale Mysteries: The Beach Murder (2017)

The body of a young internet entrepreneur, Garrett Winters gets located by police floating on the ocean. Upon investigation, police concludes that the death was due to a surfing accident.

Garett’s wife, Annie doesn’t belives that it was an accident, she goes to Jennifer’s antique shop to sell the e-store because Garrett had a collection of old and valuable surfboards and explains everything to Jennifers. Jennifers to help Annie and uncover what actually happened decides to start her own investigation.

A still from Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder By Text (2017). it is the ninth movie on the list of all Garage Sale Mystery series

Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder By Text (2017)

While preparing for their upcoming concert, Famous country singer John Dalton’s and his team finds the dead body of one of their member Lita, the band’s bassist. The police arrive and start their investigation in which everything looks clear that it is a suicide.

Jennifer, as usual, believes her instincts and thinks that there is foul play and starts her investigation. When she discovers that a Taser was used to immobilize her before her death, her doubt turns into reality and she starts to work on the case with dedication to find who is behind all this.

A still from Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder Most Medieval (2017). it is the tenth movie on the list of all Garage Sale Mystery series

Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder Most Medieval (2017)

While traveling around the town to find antiques, Jennifer finds a new client, and for him, she purchases a 15th-century suit of armor. When she starts to check the suit, she gets shocked to find the body of a local college history professor.

Jennifer starts to look for the evidence that will help her unpuzzle the mystery, but soon she realizes that she has been trapped in the killer’s web of dangerous lies.

A still from Garage Sale Mysteries: A Case of Murder (2017). it is the eleventh movie on the list of all Garage Sale Mystery series

Garage Sale Mysteries: A Case of Murder (2017)

While looking for new antiques which can be resold in her antique shop, Jennifer purchases an old reel-to-reel recorder. While checking the condition of the recorder, Jennifer plays it and is shocked to listen to the voice of a man pleading for his life.

Jennifer initially gets confused about the incident, but when she listens to the tape carefully, she gets some clues that will help her start her investigation and find who the culprit is.

A still from Garage Sale Mysteries: The Pandora’s Box Murders (2018). it is the twelfth  movie on the list of all Garage Sale Mystery series

Garage Sale Mysteries: The Pandora’s Box Murders (2018)

After solving many crime mysteries, amateur sleuth Jennifer Shannon becomes the talk of the town and gets an invitation to appear on a new reality TV series. While she goes for the show’s shooting, she encounters a puzzle box with clues to reach the killer of the creator of the puzzle box.

Jennifer initially ignores the box, but when the dead woman’s daughter-in-law is found just after the two days of the incident, Jennifer thinks that there is something serious going on and decides to investigate.

A still from Garage Sale Mysteries: The Mask Murder (2018). it is the twelfth  movie on the list of all Garage Sale Mystery series

Garage Sale Mysteries: The Mask Murder (2018)

Even after becoming a famous crime mystery detective in the town, Jennifer continues her work of hunting treasure around the town and reselling it in her antique shop. Jennifer Shannon, along with her business partner Dani, purchases a storage locker in an auction.

Upon opening the storage locker, she finds a dead body inside, which shocks both of them further. They find a “death mask” that perfectly fits the dead woman. After the incident, Jennifer starts to begin her investigation to uncover the actual truth.

A still from Garage Sale Mysteries: Picture a Murder (2018). it is the fourteenth movie on the list of all Garage Sale Mystery series

Garage Sale Mysteries: Picture a Murder (2018)

Larry Brady died of a heart attack during his 60th birthday party. The death looks natural, and police, after their investigation, concludes that Larry died due to a heart attack. Everyone accepts that Larry died due to a heart attack but their nephew, Tony, has some doubts!

Tony starts to investigate Larry’s death, but when it seems too complex for him, he takes help from his high school classmate’s mom, Jennifer Shannon.

A still from Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder in D Minor (2018). it is the fifteenth movie on the list of all Garage Sale Mystery series

Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder in D Minor (2018)

After the death of a local art collector, all his collections are put on auction, from which Rags to Riches shop owner, Jennifer Shannon along with her business partner Dani purchases a rare piece.

While trying to find the provenance of the entire collection, Jennifer gets trapped in the puzzle of pre-meditated murder.

A still from Garage Sale Mysteries: Search & Seized (2019). it is the sixteenth movie on the list of all Garage Sale Mystery series

Garage Sale Mysteries: Search & Seized (2019)

Even After solving many crime mysteries, Jennifers doesn’t leave her work looking for antique treasure that she can resell in her shop.

While Jennifers are running her shop, One of the old friends, Miles, turns up dead while managing a police auction that features items seized in a money counterfeiting operation. To find out who is behind the killing of her friend, Jennifer starts her investigation.

Will There Be More Garage Sale Mysteries?

Search & Seized (2019) is the last film. There will be no more garage sale mysteries because, In 2019, lead actress Lori Loughlin was arrested in connection to the College Admissions Bribery Scandal, Hallmark abruptly ended the film series.

Which Garage Sale Mystery Movie Is The Best?

The Garage Sale Mysteries are beloved by many, but some of the films lacked how they concluded. Here is a list of all Garage Sale Mystery movies ranked from worst to best based on audience ratings on IMDb.

Garage Sale MysteriesIMDb Ratings
The Art or Murder6.8/10
Murder by Text6.8/10
Search & Seized6.8/10
Garage Sale Mystery6.9/10
The Wedding Dress6.9/10
The Beach Murder6.9/10
Murder Most Medieval6.9/10
All That Glitters7.0/10
The Deadly Room7.0/10
Guilty Until Proven Innocent7.0/10
The Novel Murders7.1/10
A Case of Murder7.1/10
The Mask Murder7.1/10
Pandora’s Box7.1/10
Murder In D Minor7.2/10
Picture a Murder7.2/10

Other Popular Television Mystery Series From Hallmark

Conclusion

Garage Sale Mystery series is a popular crime mystery series created by hallmark. The series currently has sixteen episodes that can be watched on the hallmark channel.

The series has a chronological follow, with every movie picking the story from the end in the previous film. Here in this article, we have listed all Garage Sale Mystery movies in order of release, which you can follow to watch the entire series.

1 thought on “Every Single Garage Sale Mystery Movie (In Release Order)”

  1. Everything is very open with a clear description of the challenges.

    It was truly informative. Your site is very helpful. Thanks for sharing!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *